California

Started by Ararar, Aug 22, 2025, 05:35 PM

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Previous topic - Next topic

Redzone

*****
Hero Member
Posts: 1,137
Logged
Quote from: TheOC89 on Nov 23, 2025, 01:06 PMHA!.... The Reason RSM doesn't let him throw the ball is he is not that good.... And they did let him throw the Ball, 35+ times against both BG and Servite and he stunk.... He Stunk against SJB as well, he had 13 completions 9 of them to #4, If he didn't have #4 he struggled terribly....

I don't care what the MD kid did in 1 game against SJB, he stunk the rest of the season.... Didn't even complete 60% of his passes and 12 of his 16 TD's went to 2 players.... The Top 2 wideouts where he just threw up 50/50 balls.... 🤣

Anyone who has watched both of these QB's play can tell you they are not D1 players and won't start at the next level....


Now you can say you have seen the highlights of Santa Margarita vs Sierra Canyon.

Try watching a game. 🤠 Ha!

https://www.maxpreps.com/video/watch/santa-margarita-rides-trace-johnson-s-efficient-night-to-21-9-victory-over-sierra-canyon/?v=19637361-083f-44f3-8ac6-52257f188104

Bodysurf

*
Newbie
Posts: 43
Logged
Quote from: Steeler01 on Nov 22, 2025, 04:23 PMMD wasn't as talented as last year to overcome Lara. This was the least talented MD team since 2015 easily.
Wrong. It was very talented. The difference is that we had a huge downgrade at the QB position that could not be overcome by the incredibly talented roster.

Steeler01

****
Sr. Member
Posts: 459
Logged
Quote from: Bodysurf on Nov 23, 2025, 04:25 PMWrong. It was very talented. The difference is that we had a huge downgrade at the QB position that could not be overcome by the incredibly talented roster.
Very talented, and MD talented the last couple of years are two different things.

TheOC89

****
Sr. Member
Posts: 282
Logged
Quote from: Redzone on Nov 23, 2025, 01:52 PMNow you can say you have seen the highlights of Santa Margarita vs Sierra Canyon.

Try watching a game. 🤠 Ha!

https://www.maxpreps.com/video/watch/santa-margarita-rides-trace-johnson-s-efficient-night-to-21-9-victory-over-sierra-canyon/?v=19637361-083f-44f3-8ac6-52257f188104

HA!!... You mean the Sierra Canyon who you touted as the #2 team in Your Poll, who was a total fraud and played a crap schedule?.... That Sierra Canyon?.... Doubt they would even beat Servite this year.... 🤣

I don't have to watch the highlights to know that he didn't even crack 200 yards passing and if he threw any TD's they probably went to #4....

Redzone

*****
Hero Member
Posts: 1,137
Logged
Quote from: Wooderson on Nov 23, 2025, 12:48 PMJohnson's a six-foot-tall quarterback with 15 touchdown passes and less than 100 rushing yards as a senior; pretty objectively he's gotten more collegiate attention than his profile would otherwise dictate.

As for the Mater Dei quarterback, let's engage in a thought experiment and say that at the end of this season Wisconsin chooses to fire their HC (not outside the realm of possibilities). The new HC decides not to honor the offer to the MDQB, and MDQB is now back on the market. If that were to happen, what's the best outcome he could expect considering that 9 of the remaining 11 schools who have offered him already have QB commits, and five of those are guys ranked definitively better than MDQB.

When I see the nation's top prep program have a QB with measurables but nothing but a bunch of mid-tier D1 offers that's a red flag to me. You know every scout in the country has seen MDQB play and outside of UCF, Kentucky, Wisconsin, and a host of other "eh" programs the response has been "no thanks".

I personally think 3* QB Luke Fahey from Mission Viejo could possibly be overrated, but then again I didn't watch every single game Mission Viejo played this year. He didn't look very impressive the couple times I did see him play...... looked terrible against the Hillbilly team.

He's committed Ohio State and doesn't really look like the kind of QB Ohio State recruits. BUT, maybe they know more than I do.

https://247sports.com/player/luke-fahey-46146282/

Redzone

*****
Hero Member
Posts: 1,137
Logged
#530
Quote from: Bodysurf on Nov 23, 2025, 04:25 PMWrong. It was very talented. The difference is that we had a huge downgrade at the QB position that could not be overcome by the incredibly talented roster.

You almost had a great post. 🤠

The QB's normally the guy they blame though, right?

I mean you did beat STA, Bishop Gorman, SJB and etc with that totally terrible QB that was such a downgrade.

To me this year's version of Mater Dei just wasn't very disciplined in several phases of the game.

But that's just me.

Redzone

*****
Hero Member
Posts: 1,137
Logged
Quote from: TheOC89 on Nov 23, 2025, 07:43 PMHA!!... You mean the Sierra Canyon who you touted as the #2 team in Your Poll, who was a total fraud and played a crap schedule?.... That Sierra Canyon?.... Doubt they would even beat Servite this year.... 🤣

I don't have to watch the highlights to know that he didn't even crack 200 yards passing and if he threw any TD's they probably went to #4....

So I had Sierra Canyon ranked a couple spots higher than the National Polls. Everyone was sold on Sierra Canyon.
Who cares?
Everyone was sold on Mater Dei then St John Bosco too. 🤠 Ha!

AND
Everyone beats Servite!

Redzone

*****
Hero Member
Posts: 1,137
Logged
Is Centennial's QB Dominick Catalano overrated?
He's 5'10 175 lbs and rated a 2-star with 0 offers.
I think 247sports gives every player in California some "stars". They don't even do 2-stars in Louisiana. Crazy stuff.
🤠 Ha!4

https://247sports.com/player/dominick-catalano-46152022/

Catalano passed for 290 Yards, rushed for 2 TDs and threw the game winning TD pass.

So in the Southern Section Final we have an overrated 3* QB vs the overrated 2* QB.💪



AztecPadre

**
Jr. Member
Posts: 97
Logged
I blame the boosters/alumni of MD for this season.  Had they kept coach Frank, they would be undefeated and national champs, again. lol

Belly Bob

*
Newbie
Posts: 5
Logged
Quote from: On2Wheels on Nov 21, 2025, 10:31 PMI know this is supposed to be football only, but I had to watch this one on NFHS from my room at City of Hope.  I'm 8 days past stem cell introduction  and I still can't believe they pulled it off.  Now, if I can fight liked the Huskies, maybe I'll see a championship.

That sounds serious. I was stage 4, fully metastatic. That was 8 years ago. I've missed some big games because of hospital stays. But I've been in full remission for 3 years now. Hang tough. I'll make sure to include you in my prayers.

Wooderson

**
Jr. Member
Posts: 79
Logged
Quote from: Redzone on Nov 23, 2025, 08:40 PMI personally think 3* QB Luke Fahey from Mission Viejo could possibly be overrated, but then again I didn't watch every single game Mission Viejo played this year. He didn't look very impressive the couple times I did see him play...... looked terrible against the Hillbilly team.

He's committed Ohio State and doesn't really look like the kind of QB Ohio State recruits. BUT, maybe they know more than I do.

https://247sports.com/player/luke-fahey-46146282/

Fahey is a three year starter with fewer than ten interceptions over those three seasons and is a legitimate dual threat QB. None of that means he's going to be a success at the next level (odds are none of these guys will be) but it's pretty easy to understand why he has 27 D1 offers (five of those are from teams currently positioned to make this year's playoffs; rather convenient that you left these parts out) and viewed as a better prospect than Johnson.

Redzone

*****
Hero Member
Posts: 1,137
Logged
Quote from: Wooderson on Nov 24, 2025, 04:15 PMFahey is a three year starter with fewer than ten interceptions over those three seasons and is a legitimate dual threat QB. None of that means he's going to be a success at the next level (odds are none of these guys will be) but it's pretty easy to understand why he has 27 D1 offers (five of those are from teams currently positioned to make this year's playoffs; rather convenient that you left these parts out) and viewed as a better prospect than Johnson.

I didn't leave anything out.
I posted his profile for all to see and he's an Ohio State commit..

I watched him play 2 complete games this year and wasn't impressed. When you hear Ohio State commit you expect to see "really special", right?

But like I said in my post maybe Ohio State knows more than I do.


Redzone

*****
Hero Member
Posts: 1,137
Logged
I read where Mater Dei's 3*  overrated QB Ryan Hopkins ran a 10.66 100 Meters this year ........ that's very fast.

Does Mater Dei even use any of that speed?


TheCompPoll

Administrator
*****
Sr. Member
Posts: 282
Logged
Quote from: Redzone on Nov 24, 2025, 05:36 PMI read where Mater Dei's 3*  overrated QB Ryan Hopkins ran a 10.66 100 Meters this year ........ that's very fast.

Does Mater Dei even use any of that speed?


You tell us, you're obviously the expert on Mater Dei's talent

Redzone

*****
Hero Member
Posts: 1,137
Logged
Quote from: TheCompPoll on Nov 24, 2025, 05:43 PMYou tell us, you're obviously the expert on Mater Dei's talent


What I can tell you is he had 500 Yards rushing and 8 rushing TDs at JSerra Catholic last year.