Formal petition

Started by Nolebull813, Sep 22, 2026, 05:39 PM

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Previous topic - Next topic

TheCompPoll

Administrator
*****
Sr. Member
Posts: 403
Logged
Quote from: Cossacks on Sep 23, 2026, 06:16 PMI do agree with most of this, but what exactly is the definition of a "hobby" poll, one which doesn't cost $$?

Again I can see it both ways. But I was on the CalHi \StudentSports pages in the late 90's and early 2000's when it was free and its' rankings to me were just as good as what they are now. Nelson Tennis started CalHi as a hobby actually.

That's a fair question. Currently I would say to not be considered "hobbyist" a poll or ranking would have to meet at least one of the following criteria:

  • Must be generated by legitimate computer algorithms (e.g., CalPreps/HSRatings, Massey, etc.)
  • Must be associated with (or formerly associated with) a major media outlet or syndication (e.g., USAToday, Sports Illustrated, ESPN etc.)
  • Have wide reach and established pedigree within the HSFB world (MaxPreps, etc.)

TheCompPoll

Administrator
*****
Sr. Member
Posts: 403
Logged
Quote from: DreadnaughtAlum on Sep 23, 2026, 05:25 PM"Hobbyist polls" figure to be better because they are run by people...doing it as a hobby. Which means they're real fans who enjoy following the game. The media rankings lists tend to be run by folks doing it as a job, and are not intrinsically motivated to gain the most knowledge. Perhaps there can be some sort of objective measure that would distinguish credible hobbyist rankings from those done to serve some other interest. But, I don't think a rankings list compiled by a twentty-something dummy from New York City who happened to get hired by a renown publication that doesn't even specialize in or focus on high school football is inherently better than one done by a fan who does it for fun.

I don't disagree. I already acknowledged the quality of Omaha Vol's and Whiteshoes' rankings. The crux though is whether or not they have wide reach, recognition and are regularly cited by others in the HSFB landscape. I think I could also compile my own subjective ranking that would be likely be better than most of the people working for the major media outlets. But if I did, I wouldn't expect everyone to start acknowledging and citing my rankings. If their rankings (or any hobbyist ranking) gains traction and becomes widely recognized within the HSFB landscape, then yes I would absolutely consider it for inclusion in the comp poll.

DreadnaughtAlum

****
Sr. Member
Posts: 264
Logged
Quote from: TheCompPoll on Sep 24, 2026, 08:36 AMI don't disagree. I already acknowledged the quality of Omaha Vol's and Whiteshoes' rankings. The crux though is whether or not they have wide reach, recognition and are regularly cited by others in the HSFB landscape. I think I could also compile my own subjective ranking that would be likely be better than most of the people working for the major media outlets. But if I did, I wouldn't expect everyone to start acknowledging and citing my rankings. If their rankings (or any hobbyist ranking) gains traction and becomes widely recognized within the HSFB landscape, then yes I would absolutely consider it for inclusion in the comp poll.
Another idea is to offer two "comp polls". One as you have now, but then another can include every rankings list we have reason to be is of enough quality to be worth looking at. For example on the on3 site, you have both a rivals composite poll, and the Massey ratings on a separate tab. Their rankings page defaults to the Rivals composite, leaving interested viewers to deliberately click over to see the Massey ratings. Yours could have the primary or "official" comp poll ratings and then the othe tab could be those with additions for other rankings lists of interest.

Redzone

*****
Hero Member
Posts: 3,607
Logged
#18
Nm